Copart, Inc. (CPRT) Stock Analysis

44.0/100
Sell ✓ Halal Industrials
Price $31.83
Market Cap $29.49B
52-Week Change -23.52%

Is CPRT a good investment?

Copart, Inc. (CPRT) has a Plutrex AI rating of 44.0/100 as of November 12, 2026, indicating a Sell consensus. The stock is halal-compliant per AAOIFI standards. Key strength: Profitability moat unmatched in peer group: operating margin 35.4% is +113% above industry average 16.6%; net margin 31.8% is +202% above industry average 10.5% — CPRT retains $0.318 of net income per dollar of revenue, reflecting genuine network-effect moat in salvage vehicle auctions that peers cannot replicate. Main concern: Valuation continues to worsen with no fundamental catalyst: P/E expanded from 18.67x to 20.74x (+11.1%), PEG worsened from 2.62x to 2.91x (+11.1%), analyst upside compressed from 23.6% to 11.3% — the stock has now risen +22.0% since the entry zone ($25.50–$27.00) with zero revenue growth improvement (stuck at 2.4%), zero analyst target revision ($35.80 unchanged), and risk/reward at current price is barely 1:1 to analyst target vs. meaningful downside to any fundamental support level.

Investment Summary

CPRT is a genuinely exceptional business — operating margin of 35.4% (vs. industry 16.6%), net margin of 31.8% (vs. industry 10.5%), D/E of 0.01x vs. industry 0.73x, and $4.49B in cash — trading at a price that has now moved further away from fundamental justification. The stock is up another +11.1% since the prior report (from $28.96 to $32.17) with zero fundamental improvement: revenue growth unchanged at 2.4%, analyst target unchanged at $35.80, P/E expanded from 18.67x to 20.74x, PEG worsened from 2.62x to 2.91x. Analyst upside has compressed from 23.6% to only 11.3% ($35.80 target vs. $32.17 current). The ACV acquisition ($1.9B) adds diversification into the $100B+ used-car wholesale market, which is a genuine positive for long-term growth, but a KSF law firm investigation into deal process adequacy ('Law firm KSF is investigating the adequacy of the price and process of the proposed sale') creates integration overhang. The stock is now trading 19% above the prior entry zone of $25.50–$27.00, with risk/reward deteriorating sharply: upside to analyst target is $3.63 (11.3%) while downside to reasonable stop at $29.00 is $3.17 — barely 1:1. This is not an investable risk/reward profile. The recommendation is unchanged: HOLD existing positions; do NOT add or initiate at current prices.

Key Strengths

Key Concerns

Plutrex 10-Factor AI Breakdown

Financial Health
92/100
Growth Potential
16/100
Valuation
32/100
Profitability
88/100
Debt Management
95/100
Analyst Sentiment
48/100
Technical Momentum
38/100
Insider Confidence
28/100
News Sentiment
72/100

Fundamental Analysis

CPRT's business quality remains exceptional and unchanged: gross margin 44.1% (vs. industry 31.8%, +38% premium), operating margin 35.4% (vs. industry 16.6%, +113% premium), net margin 31.8% (vs. industry 10.5%, +202% premium). ROE of 16.2% is slightly below industry 17.9% but only because the $4.49B cash hoard dilutes the equity base — underlying returns on deployed capital are far superior. D/E of 0.01x vs. industry 0.73x — CPRT carries 73x less leverage than peers. FCF of $1.27B annually is robust. These are real competitive moat indicators. However, the growth profile is structurally weak: revenue growth 2.4% vs. industry 8.0% (a 70% deficit), TTM earnings growth -15.0% vs. industry +23.0% (a 38-percentage-point gap), 5-year forward EPS growth 7.1% vs. industry 12.1% (a 41% deficit). P/E of 20.74x — this appears reasonable in isolation but against 7.1% 5-year EPS growth, a PEG of 2.91x (vs. the Lynch fair value threshold of 1.0x) indicates the market is paying nearly 3x a growth-justified multiple. At PEG 1.0x, fair P/E = 7.1x; at a generous quality-premium PEG of 1.5x, fair P/E = 10.65x. Even at PEG 2.0x (a heroic premium), fair P/E = 14.2x — implying a fair value range of approximately $22–$25, well below the current $32.17. The forward 9.3% next-year EPS recovery is encouraging but must be sustained to close the gap.

News Sentiment

Copart is making big moves, but investors are paying a steep price for the privilege. The salvage vehicle auction giant recently completed its $1.9 billion acquisition of ACV Auctions — a digital wholesale marketplace — in what the company is billing as a transformational expansion beyond its traditional salvage car business. As confirmed by the headline 'Copart Completes Acquisition of ACV,' the deal is now done, removing the uncertainty that had hung over the stock for months. Management is positioning ACV alongside international insurance, domestic whole-car remarketing, and tech-enabled services as 'multi-year growth pillars' — a clear acknowledgment that the core salvage auction business, while profitable, needs new growth engines. One analyst has called Copart 'My Highest Conviction Position Trading At A Discount,' citing inflation-resistant pricing power and durable competitive advantages — suggesting the company can maintain its extraordinary 35% operating margins even in tough economic times. Meanwhile, Copart has been highlighted as one of three stocks that 'Own Hard Assets,' reinforcing the view that its vast network of salvage yards and vehicle lots represents a unique real-asset moat. The fly in the ointment: law firm KSF is investigating whether ACV's board conducted a fair process and paid the right price — a legal cloud that could drag on for months. And another analyst notes that 'Cyclical U.S. Weakness Masks Long-Term Growth And Valuation Upside,' acknowledging near-term headwinds while remaining optimistic about the long game. For everyday investors, the story is straightforward: great company, steep price, and a deal that needs to prove itself.

Risk Assessment

PRIMARY RISK: Valuation compression. At P/E 20.74x on 7.1% 5-year EPS growth (PEG 2.91x), any multiple re-rating toward the growth-justified range (P/E 10–14x) implies 32–52% downside from current price — a $15–$22 range. With analyst target at $35.80 (only 11.3% upside), the asymmetry is deeply unfavorable at current prices. SECONDARY RISK: ACV integration. The $1.9B acquisition of ACV Auctions carries execution risk — integrating a tech-enabled wholesale platform into CPRT's salvage auction infrastructure is non-trivial. The KSF law firm investigation into the deal process adds legal costs and management distraction. If ACV's wholesale margins are lower than CPRT's core business (likely), blended margins may compress in the near term. TERTIARY RISK: Cyclical earnings recovery failure. The -15% TTM earnings decline is assumed to be cyclical (post-pandemic vehicle price normalization), but if the 9.3% next-year recovery forecast disappoints, the investment thesis cracks further. MITIGATION: Existing holders are protected by the fortress balance sheet ($4.49B cash, D/E 0.01x) which provides a floor — the company will not be in financial distress. Wait for the entry zone of $26.50–$28.00 (P/E ~16-17x, PEG ~2.3x, analyst upside ~28–35%) before initiating or adding.

Related Halal Stocks

Related Stocks

Frequently Asked Questions

Is CPRT a halal stock?

Yes, Copart, Inc. (CPRT) is halal-compliant per AAOIFI standards as of the latest quarterly review.

What is Plutrex's AI rating for CPRT?

Copart, Inc. (CPRT) has a Plutrex AI rating of 44.0/100 with a Sell consensus, based on a 10-factor analysis covering financial health, growth, valuation, profitability, debt, analyst sentiment, technical momentum, insider confidence, news sentiment, and halal compliance.

Is CPRT a good investment?

According to Plutrex AI, CPRT has a Sell rating (44.0/100). For the full analysis including trading plan and risk assessment, see the detailed breakdown above.

How can I invest in CPRT?

US stocks like CPRT can be bought through international brokers such as Interactive Brokers, accessible to Arab investors. ElBarake provides comprehensive analysis plus AI-generated trading plans with entry points, stop losses, and profit targets.

What are the main risks of investing in CPRT?

Plutrex AI identifies the main risks for CPRT by analyzing valuation, debt, market sentiment, and macro factors. See the Risk Assessment section above for the full breakdown.

Chat with ElBarake AI about CPRT

Ask anything about this stock and get an instant AI-powered answer — free, no signup required.

Open CPRT in ElBarake